I consulted my neighbor, The Woodworker, and he says I could shine this puppy right up with some sanding and polyurethane. Now that the snow has finally melted, I can start looking into that. The latch is busted, as you can see, but it shouldn't be that hard to find a new one.
Hopefully the scratches come out of the top after some TLC.
I think I'll leave the hinges alone.
Maybe it will be a little too big for all of the ornaments? Also here's my French Hen: